in News Departments > New & Noteworthy
print the content item

comments: 10



Even as the costs of solar power continue to decline, a widespread perception from the public and many policymakers that solar is "too expensive" remains stubbornly in place - much to the frustration of advocates and industry professionals.

A new study challenges this assumption by delving into the numbers to compare the actual costs and benefits of solar power projects. The results confirm several key widespread public benefits of solar power and could provide the industry with a valuable weapon in the public-perception fight - a battle that remains crucial for long-term viability and growth.

The report, authored by Richard Perez at the University of Albany, Ken Zweibel at the GW Solar Institute and Thomas E. Hoff of Clean Power Research, focuses on tangible benefits that solar power generation delivers to utilities, ratepayers and taxpayers.

"It is clear that some possibly large value of solar energy is missed by traditional analysis," the report says.

Notably, these advantages apply to a wide population, thus providing a rebuttal to the "what's in it for me?" argument. Many other well-known recent studies on solar power's benefits focus on real - but not public - benefits. For instance, the average taxpayer may not care that his neighbor's rooftop PV array has raised that home's value or that the solar sector has created jobs for other people.

The new study, titled "Solar Power Generation in the U.S.: Too expensive or a bargain?," finds that, in all, solar PV installations deliver $0.15/kWh to $0.40/kWh to ratepayers and taxpayers.

Although incentives have proven to be a vital driver of solar power growth, the report's authors argue that the gulf between "inexpensive" conventional energy and "expensive" solar is smaller than often portrayed, especially when solar's public benefits are taken into account.

"This large apparent 'grid-parity gap' can hinder constructive dialogue with key decision makers and constitutes a powerful argument to weaken political support for solar incentives, especially during tight budgetary times," the authors wrote.

Instead, according to the report, incentives can be viewed as a logical means of transferring value from the public - which is enjoying solar's $0.15/kWh to $0.40/kWh benefits - to those who invested in the solar plants creating those benefits.

Where did the public-benefit dollar figure come from? What are these benefits, exactly? The report breaks down solar power's public value into the following nine accrued benefits (based on an analysis of relatively non-sunny New York City):

1. Savings on wholesale energy ($0.06-$0.11/kWh, of the total $0.15/kWh-$0.40/kWh). Locally generated electricity from solar installations reduces the amount of power utilities must purchase at higher prices on the wholesale market.

2. Reduction of demand-response expenses ($0.00-$0.05/kWh). "PV installations can deliver the equivalent of capacity, displacing the need to purchase this capacity elsewhere, e.g., via demand response," the report explains.

3. Savings on energy losses within the distribution system ($0.00-$0.01/kWh). Electrical losses typically incurred when energy is moved from large power plants to local loads can be avoided with distributed solar plants sited close to the load.

4. Reduced need for feeder equipment upgrades ($0.00-$0.03/kWh)
. Because distributed PV can deliver capacity at the feeder level, it can reduce the wear and tear on transformers and other feeder equipment.

5. Hedge against fuel-price spikes ($0.02-$0.03/kWh). "Solar energy does not depend on commodities whose prices fluctuate on short-term scales and will likely escalate substantially over the long term," the report says.

6. Grid security aid ($0.03-$0.06/kWh). Solar power's ability to closely mirror peak power demand can help reduce the chances of blackouts that can occur when the existing power system is overly stressed. Power outages currently cost the U.S. economy approximately $100 billion annually, according to the report.

7. Health-related and environmental gains ($0.03-$0.06/kWh). The deployment of solar power displaces the greenhouse gas emissions, mining-related consequences, water contamination, and other environmental- and health-related damages associated with fossil fuels. The $0.03-$0.06/kWh figure cited is "certainly a conservative range," the report adds.

8. Long-term taxpayer benefits from reduced fuel-price volatility ($0.03-$0.04/kWh). Using an estimate of a 150% rise in fuel-based generation costs by 2036 (deemed a conservative estimate), the report found that the "insurance hedge" of solar generation contributes a significant long-term value (in addition to the short-term fuel-price hedge value mentioned earlier).

9. Economic boost. The job-creation benefits of solar power have been demonstrated in numerous studies. Moreover, "Job creation implies value to society in many ways, including increased tax revenues, reduced unemployment and an increase in general confidence conducive to business development," the report explains.

    Photo credit: U.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory


    Hse SandyHook
    Latest Top Stories

    Test Centers Report On PV Module Durability Initiative

    Fraunhofer test laboratories have issued their first report on PV module durability based on a new test regime meant to simulate real-world conditions in a variety of climates over time. What does it take to be world-class solar?


    Global PV Thrives As Reports Say Renewables Hit $244 Billion In 2012

    Two international reports on global renewable energy spending say investments dipped last year due in part to falling solar prices. However, overall demand remained strong, notably in developing economies.


    Report Says Solar Was 48% Of New U.S. Electric Capacity In Q1 Of 2013

    According to a new industry report, the U.S. installed 723 MW of new solar capacity in the first quarter of this year, a 33% increase over the same quarter of 2012. What does the future hold?


    EU Publishes Duty Rates On Chinese Solar Products

    The European Commission reveals the duty rates it plans to impose on Chinese solar firms come Aug. 6. Which companies will face the highest tariffs?


    EU Imposes Chinese Solar Tariffs: A Prod Rather Than A Slap?

    The European Commission has decided to impose long-expected tariffs on solar products from China. However, the rate is lower than initially anticipated, with increases slated if trade talks break down. Will the program produce a deal or spark a trade war?

    lpReply
    03 Aug : 10:05
    Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    what garbage
    AnonymousReply
    03 Aug : 10:29
    Re: Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    this was such as smart and substantiated comment ;)
    larry kelleyReply
    03 Aug : 10:32
    Re: Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    For the person who said "what garbage".
    Educate yourself plaeae!
    Mike sauberReply
    03 Aug : 10:53
    Re: Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    "what garbage" , a Fox "news" type sound bite doesn't help us at all. Please explain what is "garbage" in the article.
    AnonymousReply
    03 Aug : 11:24
    Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    So lp - why don't you give us some facts/figures to uphold your garbage slinging. Last i knew this was an adult discussion board but of course you have every right to choose your behavior.
    CEMReply
    03 Aug : 14:24
    Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    Seems much more sensible to me to provide subsidies to growing businesses that provide new, longer lasting jobs, than continue to pour tax dollars to already profitable, old technologies that pollute our air and water. We are talking about new jobs here, something that some members of our congress seem to be neglecting.
    GSSE Reply
    03 Aug : 18:03
    Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    Sounds like the numbnut that commented "garbage" is either: part of the gangster power utility faction and that's how his bread is buttered , or he or she does not have clients that realize all the positive benefits of PV power generation. All my clients enjoy reduced over head, fixed energy costs, while also enjoying and providing the added benefits listed in article namely the net effects of the removing the need for the grid to provide them electricity during heavy use periods and all that it translates into, plus receiving $$$ when the operations are idle and they are producing power from the sun!
    AnonymousReply
    06 Aug : 15:18
    Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    LP = 'liquid propane' or 'Lust for petroleum' maybe?? Scared of losing sales "LP"?
    cleanenergy4ncReply
    07 Aug : 23:24
    Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    It seems pretty clear that a large number of Americans (not to mention people all over the world) are very much in favor of expanding adoption of renewable, especially solar, energy. Rather than waiting around for an impotent government to stimulate the growth of this industry, lets all make decisions every day that support solar energy in America. As Elvis said so well...."a little less conversation and a little more action".
    David DunnisonReply
    19 Aug : 17:04
    Hidden Cost Savings: The Top 9 Public Benefits Of Installing Solar Power

    Excellent list.

    Please add:
    1. Reduced/negligible capital cost escalation risk during construction. This is a big cost adder for most conventional generation projects which can take up to a decade to complete. Hydro, for example, typically sees a 50% escalation.

    2. No hidden depreciation costs and no stranded asset concerns. Some conventional plants (e.g. hydro) are depreciated over very long timeframes (e.g. 70 years). This understates the effective costs, and increases the financial impact in later years should the plant need any refurbishment.

    Regards, David (http://d-bits.com)
    Subject
    Username:
    Comment:

    Mortenson_id1102
    Mitsubishi Electric_id
    Komax_id1125
    Creotecc_id1155
    WIP_id1043
    Hilco_id1164